Finnish court issues precedent "right to be forgotten" decision for Google to remove data

The Supreme Administrative Court ruled that Google must remove a convicted man's information from its search engine data, as requested, in respect of his privacy.

The highest courts in Finland have issued a decision in a case that stands to create an important precedent. A man who had been convicted of murder has a right to privacy, and removing his information from the search engine's data is not seen to infringe on the public's right to information on important persons.

This decision to have URL links containing personal information removed from the internet is the first of its kind in Finland.

It also represents the first time that Finland has adapted the EU's "right to be forgotten" laws, introduced in May 2014. These laws make it possible to ask for personal data that is false, unnecessary, missing information or old to be deleted.

Finland's Data Protection Ombudsman put forward the data removal request because Google refused to remove the man's information at his request.

The man in question was sentenced to ten years and six months in prison for a "diminished responsibility murder" whereby defendants are not held to be fully criminally liable for their crime because their mental functions are diminished or impaired. The murder took place in 2012, and the man's imprisonment ended in July 2017.

The Supreme Administrative Court in Finland found that personal data about the man, who was convicted of murder but also found to have diminished responsibility due to a health condition, was sensitive information that can be considered private. Data on the man was also accessible via Google searches of the internet that didn't contain the man's name.

The court ruled that even though the crime in question was extremely serious, the public's right to information on the case did not outweigh the man's right to privacy and personal data protection.

Google defended itself on freedom of speech grounds

Finland's Data Protection Ombudsman first submitted the data removal request to Google over two and a half years ago.

The Ombudsman maintained that the prison sentence constituted inhuman suffering for the mentally-impaired man, and that the information on his health that was available via Google searches did irreparable damage to the man's life.

Google appealed the case to Finland's Administrative Court, which did not overturn the Ombudsman's decision, and so it continued its appeal at the Supreme Administrative Court level.

Google made the case that the data removal violated freedom of speech. Part of the EU's ruling is that some data may not be automatically deleted if it protects other rights, such as freedom of speech. For example, controversial statements made by people in the public eye, might not be deleted if public interest is best served by keeping them online. Google therefore argued that the convicted man in question was a public figure, and therefore the Finnish authorities had no business deciding what the public discussion surrounding him was like.

The Finnish court's decision will force Google's hand and make it remove the man's search engine data links. This will only remove the information from Google's search engine results, however, and not the internet in general.
Google privatedata
If you notice an error, highlight the text you want and press Ctrl + Enter to report it to the editor
1 view in december
I recommend
No recommendations yet


Post your comment to communicate and discuss this article.

A man wanted in connection with a suspected arson attempt on a home in Helsinki’s Käpylä district was remanded into police custody on Sunday. The Helsinki district court has remanded a man suspected of attempted arson and attempted murder into police custody, ending a short-lived manhunt, police said on Sunday. The 25 year-old is suspected of using a Molotov cocktail to cause a fire at a flat in Käpylä, Helsinki last Monday. The apartment was completely de...
Helsinki Central Library Oodi will opened its doors to the public on 5 December at 8am, a day before Finland’s 101st birthday. Designed by ALA Architects, this library of a new era is an ode to Finnish culture, equality and freedom of expression. Oodi offers everyone an open, public urban space at Kansalaistori Square, right opposite Parliament House. Central Library Oodi is an active and functional meeting point with 2.5 million expected annual visitors....
The teacher was convicted for nine incidents of sexual abuse that took place between 2013 and 2017. A teacher at a Swedish-language school in Helsinki was slapped with an 18-month suspended prison sentence for the sexual abuse of students in his charge. The court also ordered the defendant to pay damages amounting to 1,500 euros to one of the complainants and 1,200 euros each to four others. The court found that the offences occurred between 2013 and 2017....
Four projects will focus on resident services, data and AI, infrastructure and enablers and it aims to promote a culture of experimentation. Helsinki is continuing its drive to make the best use of digitalisation with four new projects focused on resident services, data and artificial intelligence, infrastructure and enablers, and a culture of experimentation. The Finnish capital is striving to be the world’s most “functional” city and to achieve its aims...
Police suspect a fire that destroyed a flat in Helsinki Monday night was ignited by a Molotov cocktail thrown through a window. No one was hurt in the incident. Authorities are investigating a case of suspected arson and attempted murder in Helsinki related to a fire that broke out shortly before 8 pm Monday, ravaging an apartment in the city's Käpylä neighbourhood. Police suspect that a burning Molotov cocktail, also known as a petrol bomb, was thrown thr...
The ministry also wants the national communications regulator to determine whether Trafi's other consumer services can be safely restored on Wednesday. The Ministry of Transport and Communications has asked the Finnish Communications Regulatory Authority Ficora, to assess data privacy and security on the web services of the Finnish Transport Safety Agency, Trafi. The request follows a recent public backlash to Trafi's decision to open an online database wh...
Taking a train between Finland and Estonia will be possible by Christmas 2024, says the entrepreneur behind one of two massive tunnel projects being planned. Last week the FinEst Bay Area Helsinki-Tallinn tunnel project received 100 million euros from a Dubai-based construction group ARJ Holding – the first external financing made towards the estimated 15-billion-euro effort. Peter Vesterbacka - a man who made a fortune as a marketing boss at mobile gaming...
Several protest marches took place in Helsinki on Thursday evening. Police intervened to forcibly remove swastika flags from Neo-Nazi demonstrators. Police said on Thursday that they will open an investigation into neo-Nazis flying swastika flags in downtown Helsinki. Four protesters had reportedly been taken into police custody. Two processions made their way through Helsinki city centre Thursday evening. The neo-Nazi Kohti vapautta ('toward freedom') dem...
Most of Friday’s papers focus on Thursday's gala at the Presidential Palace in Helsinki where Finland's movers, shakers and honourees were invited to celebrate the nation’s 101 years of independence. Traditionally, media attention has centered on the best-dressed guests and this year was no exception. According to tabloid Ilta-Sanomat, among the most elegant invitees this year was MP Jaana Pelkonen, who wore a bright yellow sleeveless dress by French desig...